Darlie and Darin were then taken to the hospital and the Rowlett Police Department seized the house and began their investigation. Within 11 days of the murder of Devon and Damon, the Rowlett Police Department arrested Darlie Routier, charging her with capital murder of her sons. Darlie took the stand against the advice of her counsel. They asked her why she told different versions of the story to different policemen. They asked about her dog, which barks at strangers but didn't bark when the intruder entered her home. They asked her why her kitchen was cleaned but under testing showed remnants of blood all over.
To most of the questions, Darlie answered that she didn't remember or didn't know. The jury found Darlie Routier guilty of the murder and sentenced her to death. The prosecution's case against Darlie Routier was circumstantial and based on experts who theorized about evidence collected or viewed at the crime scene. The prosecution did what it set out to do, which was to get the jury to find Darlie guilty of murder , but was all the evidence shown to the jury?
If not, why wasn't it? Websites that support Darlie Routier's appeal list many issues and facts that have come to light after her trial that, if true, would appear to provide enough evidence that a new trial would be appropriate. Some of those issues include:. The attorney that represented Darlie Routier at trial had an apparent conflict of interest because he reportedly had a pre-arrangement with Darin Routier and other family members not to pursue any defense that could implicate Darin.
This attorney allegedly stopped key experts for the defense from completing forensic examinations. Other areas of concern which were never brought to the attention of the jury include the pictures of Darlie's cuts and bruises on her arms which were taken when she was hospitalized the night of the murders.
At least one juror told reporters he would never have voted to convict if he had seen the photographs. Bloody fingerprints have been found that do not belong to Darlie, Darin, the children or any of the police or other people in the Routier house the night of the murder. This contradicts testimony given during her trial that there were no fingerprints found outside the home. Darin Routier has admitted to trying to arrange an insurance scam, which included someone breaking into their home.
He has admitted that he had begun the initial steps to arrange a break-in, but that it was to be done when no one was at home.
No jury has heard this admission. The incriminating Birthday Party film that was viewed by the jury showed Darlie dancing on the graves of her son along with other family members, but did not include the filming of the hours previous to that scene when Darlie sobbed and grieved over the graves with her husband Darin. Why was the additional footage not shown to the jury?
- The Murder Of Marilyn Sheppard.
- trail of blood a father a son and a tell tale crime scene investigation Manual;
- Operator Theory, Operator Algebras, and Applications.
- Special Edition Using Microsoft Office 2003, Student-Teacher Edition?
- Eating Disorders, Addictions and Substance Use Disorders: Research, Clinical and Treatment Perspectives.
- Science and Principles of Biodegradable and Bioresorbable Medical Polymers: Materials and Properties?
Neighbors reported seeing a black car sitting in front of the Routier home a week before the murders took place. Other neighbors reported seeing the same car leaving the area on the night of the murders. Were these reports investigated by police?
BBC News Navigation
Investigators during her trial invoked their fifth amendment rights against self-incrimination during cross-examination, preventing the defense from rebutting their testimony. What did these investigators fear by being cross-examined? There was some discussion about the police not protecting the evidence as they collected it which could have possibly damaged its origins.
- The Anatomy of Blackness: Science and Slavery in an Age of Enlightenment;
- Sin and Evil: Moral Values in Literature.
- Eye Witness Evidence!
Did this really occur? Share Flipboard Email. Government U.
- The Volunteer Management Handbook: Leadership Strategies for Success (Wiley Nonprofit Law, Finance and Management Series).
- If it hadn't been for that crazy Silly String, Darlie Lynn Routier might be a free woman today..
- The Lesser-Known Varieties of English: An Introduction (Studies in English Language).
- Biography Newsletter;
- Creativity and Artificial Intelligence: A Conceptual Blending Approach (Applications of Cognitive Linguistics).
- Did Darlie Routier kill her kids? Doubts remain two decades later.
- Ta-Nehisi Coates in Conversation with David Remnick.
Foreign Policy U. Liberal Politics U. Charles Montaldo is a writer and former licensed private detective who worked with law enforcement and insurance firms investigating crime and fraud. Updated December 30, Coroner Janice Townsend-Parchman testified that the boys' wounds were savage and deep, but described Darlie's as hesitation wounds, possibly self-inflicted.
Paramedic Larry Byford said Darlie never asked about the condition of her children when she was in the ambulance on the way to the hospital.
Charles Hamilton, a fingerprint expert who examined the scene, said that the only prints found belonged to Darlie and her children. Tom Bevel, a blood expert, testified that the blood on Darlie's nightshirt belonged to her sons. It had been sprayed on her and he suggested that this could happen as she raised her arms upward in a stabbing motion.
Nurses from the hospital testified that Darlie did not demonstrate grief towards the loss of her sons. They claimed she seemed more concerned with making a point to say she picked up the knife off the kitchen floor, which put her prints on the knife. Also mentioned was the blood found under a vacuum cleaner and blood spots on the cleaner itself, indicating that the vacuum cleaner had been placed there after the crime was committed.
Charles Linch, a trace-evidence expert, said it was impossible for an intruder to leave that scene without a trail of blood. There was no blood found outside the Routier home. FBI's special agent Al Brantley testified that the window screen that was cut could have merely been removed by an intruder.
Also that Darlie's expensive jewelry had been left untouched, discounting robbery as a motive. As to the motive being rape , he said that a rapist would have used her children as leverage to get her to submit, not killed them. And finally, he addressed the savagery of the stabbing of the boys and said that in his opinion, it was a personal attack done with extreme anger, not by a stranger. A bloody fingerprint was found on the living room table.
Who does it belong to? There was a bloody fingerprint on the door of the garage. Darin Routier's jeans had blood on them. Whose blood is it? A pubic hair was found in the Routier living room. I don't think he was expecting that. The carnage could have been worse: the Clayton children were home that night and could have died in a fire.
Nevertheless, both Thomas Clayton and Michael Beard were convicted of first and second degree murder and are currently serving life sentences without the possibility of parole in different New York State prisons. Homeowners insurance. He would've truly benefited financially from the death of all of them. Our love for Kelley, [their kids] and Thomas is unending.taylor.evolt.org/xisop-palafrugell-app-para.php
Convicted Child Killer Darlie Routier: Guilty or Railroaded?
To know Thomas would be to know that he would never kill another human being nor would he send another person in to his home to kill another human being, most of all his wife, the mother of his children. This month, an appeals court upheld Clayton's conviction. However, Clayton's attorney, Brian Shiffrin, said that next, he aims to take the case to the Court of Appeals, the state's highest court, according to the Star-Gazette.
Beard, too, is planning to appeal his case. But police say that in addition to the child's description of what happened that night her mother was killed, "the robber's" clothing she described matches exactly with Beard's bloody clothes that police later recovered. Beard also led police to the murder weapon and keys to the Clayton home, which had been tossed into the woods. The Clayton children have been very resilient after their mother's death and are doing well but are still scarred by the situation, according to Bourgeois.
The girl is now 11 and her younger brother is now 7. I want my mommy.
Sam Sheppard: The Controversial Trial Of A Young Doctor For Murder
The family is also very thankful for the support from the community -- which has raised money for the Clayton children. Purple ribbons, the symbol for domestic violence, now dot the nearby towns of Elmira and Corning, New York. Editor's Note: An updated version of this story makes the Clayton children anonymous to protect their identities. All rights reserved. Play Collene Rose. Iran continuing to do what it's done for 4 decades: Former Defense Secretary Mattis.
Chapter 3: What You Need To Know About Evidence
North Korean mother and son defectors die of suspected starvation in Seoul. Travel firm Thomas Cook holds talks to avoid a collapse. Boris Johnson heads to UN, urging world to see beyond Brexit. Florida woman jailed after video of her kicking and choking dog goes viral. Israeli president begins talks to form new government. Pakistan bus crash kills 26; brakes fail on mountain road. Warren highlights violence against transgender women of color. Steak, beer and politics: Democrats descend on Iowa.
Trump orders additional air defense troops to Saudi Arabia. Trump issues executive order to improve flu vaccine. Trump announces sanctions on Iran's national bank ahead of military options meeting. Women leave Montana town over border agency lawsuit backlash.
Related Trail of Blood. A Father, a Son and a Tell-Tale Crime Scene Investigation
Copyright 2019 - All Right Reserved